YOU -- "But what if humanity keeps letting us down?"
STEBAN, THE STUDENT COMMUNIST -- "Nobody said that fulfilling the proletariat's historic role would be easy. It demands great faith with no promise of tangible reward. But that doesn't mean we can simply give up."
STEBAN, THE STUDENT COMMUNIST -- "I guess you can say we believe it *because* it's impossible. It's our way of saying we refuse to accept that the world has to remain... like this..."

---

A 2 week old fetid corpse hangs from a tree, a ghastly sight; a human life reduced to a macabre piñata for small children to pelt stones at in a twisted idea of entertainment. The children themselves, a hopped-up junkie and a nameless orphan respectively, both the result of a broken system that has unequivocally failed them. The district of Martinaise, pockmarked by the remnants of revolutionary war, abandoned by the world at large, it and its people subject to the pissing contests of petty government officials to see who is lumped with the task of looking after the place, the site of a months-long, on-the-brink-of-warfare labor dispute that's about to boil over with the lynching of a PMC soldier who was meant to "defuse" the situation. All of this, left to the hands of a suicidal, vice-riddled husk of a cop who can barely get his necktie down from the ceiling fan without potentially going into cardiac arrest. Disco Elysium is an undeniably depressing experience that isn't afraid to cover the messy spectrum of humanity, from insane race-realist phrenologists to meth-addled children to every kind of ghoulish bureaucrat under the sun. The district of Martinaise, as fictional as it is, is a place I've seen before, reflected in the streets, reflected in the people, reflected in the system; an undeniably full-faced look at the horrors faced by those below, and the resulting apathy expressed by those above.

---

SUGGESTION -- Brother, you should put me in front of a firing squad. I have no words for how I failed you.

---

Every aspect of Disco Elysium reflects its overall theme of "failure". Martinaise itself has been failed by the institutions meant to help it, abandoned by the powers that be, who only intervene when it looks like anyone is trying to enact change. NPCs can reminisce on days gone by, of the tragedies in their past, or of their cynical rebuke of the future. The various schools of political thought you can adopt and their representatives are mercilessly picked apart, from the Communists too entrenched in theory to take notice of the suffering around them, to the frankly pathetic fascists who use their prejudiced beliefs to shield themselves from their own flaws. Our protagonist is constantly haunted by his past and even starts the game recovering from his own self-destructive ways, and on a gameplay level, the way that our intrepid detective can fumble the bag in nearly every way imaginable and still be allowed to make progress in investigations and sidequests is commendable. Failure is so integral, so vital to Disco Elysium that it's not only an aspect deeply ingrained in its story, but also its very gameplay.

---

VOLITION [Easy: Success] -- No. This is somewhere to be. This is all you have, but it's still something. Streets and sodium lights. The sky, the world. You're still alive.

---

And yet, despite this cloying cynicism and acknowledgement of the ugliness of reality, Disco Elysium is magical because of the fact that it ultimately believes that there is a world worth fighting for in the end. It would be incredibly easy to be defeatist in the face of such constant, institutional and societal failure we are presented with in Revachol, to be ceaselessly apathetic in the face of your own overwhelming shortcomings, to fall back into the comfort of old vices instead of facing our problems head on. Still, Disco Elysium has that fire inside of it, an untapped hatred for fence-sitting, for passivity in the face of oppression and valuing the status quo over any meaningful change. Roll up your sleeves and fight for a better future.

---

RHETORIC -- "You've built it before, they've built it before. Hasn't really worked out yet, but neither has love -- should we just stop building love, too?"

---

STEBAN, THE STUDENT COMMUNIST -- "In dark times, should the stars also go out?"

---

RHETORIC -- "Say one of these fascist or communist things or fuck off."

---

Disco Elysium believes in the people. It believes in humanity, no matter how messy our supposed paragons are, or how flawed our beliefs and values can be, or how cyclical we can be in the face of it all. In a city plagued by an inability to move on, Disco Elysium says that there is always a possibility of change. If two broke Communists and a junkie wino can defy the very laws of physics in a slummy apartment, no matter how briefly, with the power of their faith and co-operation; imagine what we could do as a group. As a city. As a species.

Disco Elysium says that the cup is half full. Even if we won't see the own fruits of our labor in our lifetimes, it still looks you in the eyes and says:

"The only promise it offers is that the future can be better than the past, if we're willing to work and fight and die for it," a conviction belted out by the youths of tomorrow.

"Un jour je serai de retour près de toi", written in bright burning letters across a market square.

"TRUE LOVE IS POSSIBLE/ONLY IN THE NEXT WORLD--FOR NEW PEOPLE/IT IS TOO LATE FOR US," painted on the side of an eight-story tenement.

"Disco Inferno...," a lone voice belted out through a boombox's speakers across a frost-bitten sea.

---

MANKIND, BE VIGILANT; WE LOVED YOU

Reviewed on Feb 10, 2023


16 Comments


1 year ago

First review of the year and we're starting off strong!
(Commenting for visibility because this functional website and its functional log system give me a migraine.)

1 year ago

Drop whatever y'all doin', new cone review dropped and it slapped me silly.

1 year ago

banger ass review dude!

1 year ago

Thank you all for the kind words!
@CURSE Yeah, this whole "replay reviews not showing up in the feed" is a real pain in the ass. I had an old log for my PC playthrough but had to switch over to another console & restart my playthrough due to hardware limitations, so this review is technically a "replay", I guess.
they really need to fix their shit, the site has been performing like ass for ages now

great job though, you should be proud of this one

1 year ago

Really great review

1 year ago

Standing Ovation

1 year ago

I always thought the political machinations from Disco were just a feedstick, a conundrum to be solved while showing the true colors of its message: that it's all yet another way of humans trying to put order to chaos in the Universe. And that is, in the boiling politics scheme going on in my country, a beautiful modus operandi to the world. It may be utter shit, but I can make it better for myself.

Thanks for this.

1 year ago

It's pretty interesting that this was your take away, because I played this at the same time as a friend whose one problem with this game is that it kinda shits on everything and leaves some of its most scathing critiques for the side you'd expect it to be on. I saw where he was coming from but I wasn't sure I agreed with him, and reading this I'm not sure if I'd agree that it's unequivocally against defeatism either. Just a bleak but undeniably impassioned game I guess lol

1 year ago

@appreciations @Kijimoshi @LordDarias
Thank you, I appreciate the praise.

@MalditoMur
Your welcome. I'm glad I could be of assistance.

@turdl3
I can see how someone could come away from Disco Elysium thinking the former, but I think DE's scattershot critique of all its bases works in a way other "makes fun of everyone" media doesn't because it actually believes in something at the end of the day, and it's that core of belief that makes the critiques it proposes all the more substantive and heartfelt. My experience with DE is no doubt colored by my playstyle (I ended up doing a Communist run and the Communist Vision Quest is the most openly hopeful of the 4 under the right circumstances), but I stick by my stance that Disco Elysium is "anti-defeatist", it's just more-so, "realistically optimistic": "things COULD be better", not necessarily "things WILL be better". It can feel very cynical because it acknowledges that things may not always get better, that the world is kind of ugly and often grinds people up in its gears, and that blind faith is not enough to change the world (the Communist thought even acknowledges your efforts would only build 0.0001% of Communism at the end of the day), but it does ultimately say that no matter what, the world will keep spinning, and that as long as it does, things can change. It doesn't necessarily say that the change will always be for the better, or that it'll even be good change, or it'll even stick (as shown by history, both in-game AND irl), but it says that it can happen, and it's ultimate conclusion is that humanity is a beautiful, beautiful trainwreck of a species that will more than likely burn itself out one day, but is equally capable of changing things for the better. The simple knowledge that things don't have to be like this if we can help it.

Sorry for all the text.

1 year ago

Nah that's a good reply! Just "the world will keep spinning" alone is v much the "life goes on" vibe I got from it and you did end the review on that note too.

1 year ago

Amazing review but I had to read French at the end, unfollowed

1 year ago

@C_F C'est la vie :| (Thank you!)

1 year ago

I did a lot of save-scumming on my first playthrough because I'm so worried about failing something when i think it's cool, but this review is making me want to go back and let anything happen. (I also haven't played the final cut yet, so this is solid incentive)

1 year ago

Beautiful

1 year ago

@Jackier Thank you!