Even though I liked playing this game when I was younger, it still has it's issues. I personally really liked the original game, and this one has fun level design + is pretty content rich, but the presentation and music are just not for me. I guess that's a pretty common theming that more modern Yoshi games decided to steer towards, but I just don't feel like it was the move for Island. I would still play it if you were a fan of the original, just to see what YI level design would look like after a 10 year break.