This review contains spoilers
Low expectations going in due to the reputation it has but enjoyed very much. Absolutely has faults namely its over simplifcation of investigations/evidence now without much depth to either and has maybe my least favorite case of the entire series frankly (If I have to hear "The End Justifies the Means" one more time I swear and I was scared Juniper was somehow going to be at the center of Case 5 when she showed up again).
For the story it told though overall I had a great time. Athena and Simon were great with their narrative and while it did overtake Apollo who gets the short end of the stick (As well as the other AJ character like Trucy and Klavier who feel contractual with how little they do) of the three they did pull it back with the ending. Case 4/5 saved the game for me honestly with how tightly it wrapped everything up despite its flaws, more then Case 4 in AJ at least RIP.
For the story it told though overall I had a great time. Athena and Simon were great with their narrative and while it did overtake Apollo who gets the short end of the stick (As well as the other AJ character like Trucy and Klavier who feel contractual with how little they do) of the three they did pull it back with the ending. Case 4/5 saved the game for me honestly with how tightly it wrapped everything up despite its flaws, more then Case 4 in AJ at least RIP.
2006
2022
2013
2004
2021
This review contains spoilers
Got what I wanted/expected. Gorgeous art and environments with a relaxed atmosphere, if only serviceable gameplay and minimal story. Annoyed that the robot chase sequence towards the end was only a cutscene since that could've been the only tense section of gameplay in the whole thing, but otherwise is what it says on the tin.
As a general mod it's fine. Weird as a remake of "Deep Down" with completely new maps that don't feel at all like the original levels apart from the one map in the third act in the cave taken straight from the original.
The pacing in particular I thought felt way worse (The intro in particular being a standout with the original being a quick and exciting ride in the car in at most 2 - 3 minutes to a somewhat drawn out tutorial which feels forced and literally walks you through a sight seeing tour of every mechanic) and ending (Ok the originals was pretty repetitive as well with taking down the four striders being identical, but at least it was more then a stroll through a bland uninteresting cave and then a awkward generator final boss that doesn't attack and then just cuts to black when it ends).
Would probably like more if it were sold as a new mod altogether although that doesn't excuse how weirdly bad Alyx's AI is.
The pacing in particular I thought felt way worse (The intro in particular being a standout with the original being a quick and exciting ride in the car in at most 2 - 3 minutes to a somewhat drawn out tutorial which feels forced and literally walks you through a sight seeing tour of every mechanic) and ending (Ok the originals was pretty repetitive as well with taking down the four striders being identical, but at least it was more then a stroll through a bland uninteresting cave and then a awkward generator final boss that doesn't attack and then just cuts to black when it ends).
Would probably like more if it were sold as a new mod altogether although that doesn't excuse how weirdly bad Alyx's AI is.
2018