I tired to like The Silver but couldn't. I did not like Silver Case. So I wanna start off by saying I pre-ordered the Switch version. I was genuinely looking forward to trying it out. And I wanted to play some Suda51 games before No More Heroes 3 came out cause I'm hyped. But yeah...ended up kinda disappointed instead.

You know I originally wanted to go through this trilogy. But in all honesty. I cared so little for Silver Case that it pretty much wiped any interest I had in playing Flower, Sun and Rain and the 25th Ward.

I felt Silver Case started interestingly enough but the more it continued the more confused I started to get. And the more confused I started get the less engaged I was getting with the plot. And I also realized part way through that I wasn't caring all that much for cast of characters either. This game talks about solving riddles and such. Well this whole piece of writing is a riddle. I just felt like the more played and read the more it become unintelligible word vomit. And it reminded me of when I was in high school, forced to read a book and there would times where I'll read an entire page and had no idea what happened on that page. I just did not like it's way of writing at all. I also found parts of the dungeon crawling aspect pretty tedious. Like going to room 402 repeatedly in case 2. Or having to check every floor in case 5. Overall I had hard enjoying The Silver Case. I really wanted to. The aesthetic is really cool. The soundtrack is moody and atmospheric. I'll give it points for that. But the in the end I just felt both frustrated and confused. I don't mind a story being complicated. I enjoy stuff like 13 Sentinels and Xenogears after all. Heck I'd say there parts of those stories where I didn't fully understand or found it confusing. But there were still other aspects of them that I liked, that I look can look past that and enjoy them regardless. I just don't feel the same about The Silver Case. As much as I would want to like it. It just didn't do anything for me. And that kinda does bum me out. Perhaps I'm just too stupid to understand The Silver Case I can accept that. No, I wouldn't consider it "bad" but it's definitely not for me at all.

I'll probably still play 25th Ward at the very least since it was bundled on Switch but needless to say I'm not looking forward to it and when I do play it, it probably will only be after playing No More Heroes 3.

Reviewed on Jul 27, 2021


31 Comments


To be honest you probably have the worst opinions when it comes to video games l have seen on the internet

2 years ago

You KNOW your taste is bad when even Zarathusta shits on it

2 years ago

did you play placebo? it pretty much explains a lot about the plot. you need to play in the order: transmitter > placebo > transmitter > placebo to fully understand it. there's even some chapters on placebo that starts explaining What's Going On 'Til Here. also if you think that tsc is hard to understand . . . good luck with 25th ward!

2 years ago

and no one understands 25th Ward...

2 years ago

ignore the dude not being normal about a review that essentially goes 'this isn't for me', but ye if you don't vibe with tsc i promise you that you are going to like 25w even less, abandon ship at that point. i love just about everything that this game achieves but i think it's fine to consider it an acquired taste. could absolutely benefit from a replay down the line if your tastes change and you feel differently. it's just not a 'complicated' work in the same way something with hundreds of moving pieces that fit together mostly perfectly like 13 sentinels or zero escape is

also, wrong, @hattori...i am the 25th ward understander .

2 years ago

understanding 25th ward is understanding nothing at all

2 years ago

you can understand without understanding

2 years ago

filtered

2 years ago

so many low-IQ individuals on this website who cant empathise with others or even try to attempt to understand them.... sad!

2 years ago

empathize with deez nuts homie
I did not expect to get a chain of comments...

@heatten Yes I did go through the placebo chapters. I actually liked them a little more than the transmitter chapters. Since I did they DID help me understand the plot better. Is just that after case 2 the story started to lose me and I was realizing I wasn't enjoying it much overall. So basically to me case 0,1 and 2 all the placebo chapters I'd consider "fine. Let's say 3/5 for that. While the later transmitter chapters I didn't really enjoy much. Which basically led to the opinion I have for it overall.

@Zarathusta Sorry for having bad opinions :(

2 years ago

wish i could understand the dudes getting extremely not-mad over a well-written 5/10 review

2 years ago

just here to say pkdumkipz is a tryhard loser, blocked that nerd on sight
@kingbancho you are less normal for me for unironically liking kane and lynch 2

dont worry about zara, they are a well known retard

2 years ago

Wait a minute didn't you defend the medium's choice of giving you an achievement for committing suicide?
Yea they are l act pretty dumb on this site l admit but at least l don't try to defend a video game which gives you an achievement for killing yourself
🤨 tf are you even on, tons of games give you achievements for dying like what
This comment was deleted
and my man, you literally told someone to kill themselves, you are shit
@NIRT17 l think its funny you don't know what the issue is but you call me a retard
This comment was deleted
I find it funny youre a hypocrite..oh wait I don't
you like nier automata and steins gate good reason to know you are a bad person :(
This comment was deleted
Now you're just going off on a nonsensical tangent, only makes sense
Yes because its fun and l know you will respond. Also you did instigate this so its your fault
This comment was deleted
Ah thank you for proving my point
reyn you really need to stop getting into stupid arguments choose your battles