Wow

Great narrative, but I felt it was disorienting at moments (especially in a moment the game puts you in a village to find a character and keeps pointing that he's there when he isn't, and you actually need to leave in a certain direction for you to be allowed to continue).

I imagine the experience will be way better when I replay it knowing about these inconveniences.

Good game, could've been better.
Hogwarts feels kinda dead after the initial awe, could've had less same old rpg dungeon exploring missions and more activities in the castle. A hangout system like in GTA would be cool for the companions + house friends, call them to explore the world and do some activities.

Solid 8-8.5/10 for HP fans, about 6.5-7/10 for non HP fans.