I fucking love Persona 3. But for years on end, I always avoided The Answer. Discussions online would always conclude with The Answer being nothing but just grindy, non-canon filler. An expansion not worth your time. My impressionable 14-year-old self sadly dismissed it entirely because of its reputation and moved on to other entries in the Shin Megami Tensei series. With The Answer returning to Persona 3 Reload as ($35?!) DLC, I finally decided to proceed with my belated playthrough so that I may draw fair comparisons between the original and the remake when the time comes.

It's astounding how the message of this epilogue went over so many people's heads. The Answer is such a bittersweet conclusion to my favorite game of all time and its exploration of the grief felt by the cast after the main game's ending is beautifully told, albeit the player must endure exhausting gameplay in between each impactful scene, derailing the pace a bit. Nevertheless, it's wild how many in the community misunderstood certain plot elements like Yukari's behavior or the true reasoning behind what transpired on the Promised Day. Yukari was so valid here. I don't wish to speak much about it, but I cannot figure out how The Answer mischaracterize any of its party members nor how it "ruins" the message of the main game. If anything, it elevates my feelings of the original and now I loathe myself for putting it off for so long.

Hopefully Reload's interpretation of the Answer can offer more accessibility to those put off by its increased challenge and endless dungeon crawl and its absence of the fucking compendium because seriously that choice is the only thing that really bothered me. On any note, see you in September! Maybe I'll actually jot down my thoughts about Persona 3 Reload as a whole when that time comes.

Reviewed on Mar 23, 2024


1 Comment


1 month ago

I feel the exact same way. Gameplay in the answer can be a slog but the writing is great and strengthens the themes of the base game IMO. I personally loved Yukari’s arc and I thought it and the behavior of the rest of the cast was a great representation of the different ways people and teenagers especially respond to the death of a friend. I was unlucky enough to have two friends die on separate occasions as a teenager and Yukari’s reaction is very understandable for a teenager, especially one with her past trauma, and one I’m very sympathetic towards. I get that her actions in the game are frustrating but she does have an arc, she does learn from them and gets to a healthier place re: her grief - even wanting to be roommates with Aigis the next year. I also never understood how Door-kun undoes MCs sacrifice from the base game. If anything it heightens his sacrifice! Did people miss the somewhat hamfisted Christ imagery in the Answer? No idea how people read that as him still being alive somehow. Only thing that’s ever suggested he could be brought back is a snippet of dialogue in P4 if you do the new game plus battle with Margaret which I agree is stupid and I’m glad that implication isnt in the answer.

Anyway totally understand criticisms of the gameplay but the typical criticisms of the story are totally baffling to me. Made me think I must have played a different game or something.