If this is a rating for the Eartmate Edition itself, well, it’s great. I love the artbook and the DVD had some amazing remastered tracks (Divine Wind/Wind Spirit Shrine is the best). The artbook is really nice, and I don’t need to search up what gifts everyone likes because the gifts are in the book...except for a certain RAD individual unfortunately. Only fault I suppose is having only the steelbook case, and no original case, but that’s just me being picky. Good premium edition of a good game, and was fairly priced. That is, if you bought it from the original sellers. Good luck on the second hand market with this.