I liked the first RDR more and I would even prefer the zombie one over this. Don't get me wrong though, this game was loads of fun and also hella gorgeous. I actually played almost the whole game in the first person perspective, it's that beautiful. Immense attention to detail. Yes it's longer but I've played long games before but this FELT long. It was like watching a draggy movie. It could've been paced better.
Side note: Sadie Adler for the win.