If they didn't literally throw Charlie off a cliff to write him out of the story, I think you'd have a case closer to the quality of Uncharted 2. It's not a perfect game but it captures the magic and variety of the second game really well. Incredible set pieces and encounters.

This will be the only game's multiplayer mode where I actually prestiged, or whatever they call maxing out the level cap and starting over. The multiplayer was really special for me as a teen who couldn't buy M rated games.