A beautifully crafted world with an engaging narrative. It does feel like there was alot of effort put into this game and its characters. There are many technical bugs and sometimes characters talk over each other, but it doesn't subtract from the experience too much. But there are some aspects where the game does lack in some regards, being the gameplay where the gun combat and Boss fights don't feel satisfying (but the melee combat is pretty fun). The skill trees are nice and its cool how they sometimes connect to some gamplay options, but the choices in this game usually don't feel like choices. It's not a different path rather just content you can miss out on, and sometimes these choices and dialogue options feel inconsistent with the character youre trying to build. The story is great don't get me wrong, but the campaign can also be better paced by removing alot of filler.
As for phantom liberty, it was fun to play through and its story was atleast better structured than the main game. The soundtrack and radio for this game are also amazing.