this game is perfect i would give it 6 stars if i could, i think the characters are the best crafted characters of any game ever. yes the gameplay isnt the most innovative but it is perfect to me. the scenario is perfect and i have no problem with guarma, after all the action of chapter 4 it is a very much needed change of pace, yes the island is a bit underused. the ending is my favorite part and i mean the 2 endings. the first one i knew it was coming but cried nonetheless and the second one was so satisfying. i just wished cowboys were real