It's almost impossible for me to say anything about Trials and Tribulations that even vaguely resembles objectivity. I played it at the perfect age. I was "smart" enough (lol, imagine using these games as an actual measure of intelligence) and "dumb" enough to figure out the twists exactly on pace, and have my mind annihilated by the more major turns of the final case based on my preconceptions from earlier games in the franchise. The truth is, your mileage will vary wildly with any of these games, but Trials and Tribulations was the best experience I've ever had with the end of a trilogy, and I cannot overlook that.