A Realm Reborn is a middling remake of arguably the worst game of 2010, elevated all the way to my Game of the Year list in the 2013 slot by my own stupid rules about expansions and remakes.

A Realm Reborn (what this rating applies to) is fine. Heavensward is finer. Stormblood is good. Shadowbringers and Endwalker are incredible. That's enough for the tl;dr.