The divide in quality between nearly all of the rest of the game and this is astronomical. I took off a point for horsefuck valley, but this DLC is dominated by the best area and two best bosses in the game. It looks gorgeous, every enemy is designed to be a genuine challenge while rarely annoying, the sprawling main level is one of the best designed in the series, and this is overall just some excellent content capped off with a phenomenal final battle. My only critique of the main campaign is that this is in Dark Souls II.