This is probably the most consistent Persona game of the modern Persona era. Dungeons aren't as good as in Persona 5, but they are wayy better than what 3 did. The cast is excellent, my favorite cast probably. The story is great, it definitely has more flaws than P3's story but it's overall more intriguing and I think I prefer that. Combat is obviously a bit dated but I don't really mind as the combat has never been something I cared too much about in Persona.

So yeah, my favorite story and cast of the series. If they ever remake this it's probably going to be my favorite without a doubt, and a possible 5/5. For now it still isn't quite as good as Persona 5 Royal, but it's close.