Replaying this game feels exactly the same as my first playthrough back in 2019. Most of the reasons on why I can't give RDR2 the full 5 stars is explained in NakeyJakey's video "Rockstar Games' Game Design is Outdated". To simply put, RDR2 is one of the best video games of the last decade but undeniably suffers from an inconsistent application of its realistic mechanics.