The 4 star review is for the story only. This is a great follow up from the 1st game. Vito and Joe are both amazing characters and the villains are all really good to. The world feels very lived in and throughout the different years we see different styles of cars and clothing. However the gameplay especially the shooting is extremely dated. Also I experienced multiple bugs and glitches throughout the game. This game needed the Mafia 1 remake treatment.