Idk if you'd consider Magic Cat Academy (2016) or its sequel witch games. You do seem to play as a sort of Femme cat in that one. A lot of actual great games on here to btw, Witchcraft TD and Witch Way are both great tbh

*femme magical cat

Yeah both of those were really fun. WitchWay is among my favorites, and a good motivation for me too keep looking for diamonds in the rough, as there are a lot of rough games in this list that really tested my patience.

Magic Cat Academy seems fun, but it looks more like it's mage/wizard-style than witch. Not exactly a clear distinction between the two, but I just try to limit the amount of games I need to get through, as there are a lot of explicitly named witch games.

I gotcha, good luck in your quest!

As a witch enthusiast, I can confirm that I need to play every game on this list now

You love to see it, but you should probably be vary of some of the lower rated ones on here; some of them are funny in their own way, but others will test your sanity.