I got this game because of the Pirate's DLC. It's a very hit-or-miss game. Half of the time there were some cool gameplay segments that referenced the series, and the other half, we were doing boring and repetitive statue puzzles that barely changed or evolved. There are combat segments that go on for far too long, ESPECIALLY since the combat is clunky and unintuitive.

The regular gameplay loop outside of the PotC quests is pretty fun for a bit, though. I could see some people getting really absorbed into it. You get cosmetics for your pirate and ship, so there aren't many good reasons to continue playing if the gameplay alone isn't enough for you.