Ocarina of Time’s Hyrule and Majora’s Mask Termina are both technically “open” worlds - the individual areas are segmented and limited to one place but most importantly, you can go anywhere you want, yet they still feel limiting and almost like a “hub-world”. But with Wind Waker, Nintendo took this formula and went absolutely crazy with it: Vast open-seas that you can sail across - littered with secrets like mini-games, fairy islands, indimidating enemies and side quests - the “fake” freedom that was present in OoT and MM has vanished, you can go to any part of the map and more than likely find something to do there - sound like any other game?
What makes Wind Waker so special to me though is its characters. The iteration of Ganon is far and away my favourite, the impact he makes during his short time is incredible, and I love the route they took with him; a full contrast to the man we saw in OoT. The rest of the cast is also strong, I love Tetra and the Red Lion King, and regular npcs are fun to talk with. Even the combat and general movement is improved immensely - the clunkiness that was present in the prior games while in combat is gone, and your traversal is made better because rolling is actually useful and there is now a grappling hook and a more polished hookshot. And god damn the soundtrack, Zelda games never miss the target with it but that triumphant music as you glide across the seas with the wind pushing you forward is unrivalled. The upbeat tunes of Dragon Roost and Outset island are iconic, and the evil, villainous music that plays when you enter a fight is epic. Hell, even the title track is a hit. The art style is especially notable here, at first it was downplayed when the trailer was shown but then the game released and everyone loved it. In comparison to both OoT’s and MM’s murkiness and oppressive style, Wind Waker’s is a lot more childish and artsy, which I think fits perfectly.
My only real gripe with the game is the dungeons. While the actual boss fights are incredible, I can’t help but feel underwhelmed by the actual dungeons themselves, especially when comparing them to OoT’s. Really the only good one is Forsaken Fortress, and even then I’m unsure whether to call that a dungeon, but the rest feel generic and rushed. It feels like all of the time went in to creating the world (which is completely fair). My only other nitpick is from the original game, changing the wind direction is interesting at first, but it quickly gets stale and frustrating. The remaster completely fixes this via the fast sail, a perfect addition that is only able to be obtained at a specific time, which doesn’t fully nullify the wind mechanic, but also arrives just in time for when it may get boring - fantastic game design.
Wind Waker for me is a very important game. It’s the first Zelda I ever played, and introduced me to the wonderful franchise. While I think it is an incredible game that could easily be considered a masterpiece, it feels like a premature vision of Breath of the Wild in all its ways, yet it still stands out among its contemporaries with brilliant character writing, and a world that is a joy to discover.
What makes Wind Waker so special to me though is its characters. The iteration of Ganon is far and away my favourite, the impact he makes during his short time is incredible, and I love the route they took with him; a full contrast to the man we saw in OoT. The rest of the cast is also strong, I love Tetra and the Red Lion King, and regular npcs are fun to talk with. Even the combat and general movement is improved immensely - the clunkiness that was present in the prior games while in combat is gone, and your traversal is made better because rolling is actually useful and there is now a grappling hook and a more polished hookshot. And god damn the soundtrack, Zelda games never miss the target with it but that triumphant music as you glide across the seas with the wind pushing you forward is unrivalled. The upbeat tunes of Dragon Roost and Outset island are iconic, and the evil, villainous music that plays when you enter a fight is epic. Hell, even the title track is a hit. The art style is especially notable here, at first it was downplayed when the trailer was shown but then the game released and everyone loved it. In comparison to both OoT’s and MM’s murkiness and oppressive style, Wind Waker’s is a lot more childish and artsy, which I think fits perfectly.
My only real gripe with the game is the dungeons. While the actual boss fights are incredible, I can’t help but feel underwhelmed by the actual dungeons themselves, especially when comparing them to OoT’s. Really the only good one is Forsaken Fortress, and even then I’m unsure whether to call that a dungeon, but the rest feel generic and rushed. It feels like all of the time went in to creating the world (which is completely fair). My only other nitpick is from the original game, changing the wind direction is interesting at first, but it quickly gets stale and frustrating. The remaster completely fixes this via the fast sail, a perfect addition that is only able to be obtained at a specific time, which doesn’t fully nullify the wind mechanic, but also arrives just in time for when it may get boring - fantastic game design.
Wind Waker for me is a very important game. It’s the first Zelda I ever played, and introduced me to the wonderful franchise. While I think it is an incredible game that could easily be considered a masterpiece, it feels like a premature vision of Breath of the Wild in all its ways, yet it still stands out among its contemporaries with brilliant character writing, and a world that is a joy to discover.