I can't give it a higher score than the first because of the absolutely atrocious end game that it first launched with. Luckily I played it after everything had been patched out and fixed, but imagining how long that would take to grind gave me second hand exhaustion.
That being said, leading assaults on castles was incredible, and the nemesis system gave me some amazing stories. Had one dude who just wouldn't die and followed me to the ends of the earth until he was killed by a troll for good. RIP that guy.