Though I agree that it is the worst game in the franchise, I by no means think it is bad. Yes, it is very clunky (definitely play with a controller), and isn't particularly pretty, and the new gimmick (though a good idea) was not well executed at all; but it's still got the same style of humour and story we love the series for. For that matter, I think humour is one department in which this game shines brighter than the others; the same style of jokes, but perfected to the point of being the title which made me laugh the most. If you like Monkey Island, don't skip on this title, it's worth your time.