This review contains spoilers

Lost Judgment (alongside its companion DLC; The Kaito Files, both make an absolutely killer combo, as one brilliantly supplements the other) is by far the best game RGG Studios have EVER put out to date.

Nearly everything is in tip-top shape and quite the improvement over the last game; the combat, with its wide variety of combo options and approaches to encounters; for starters, the preexisting styles; Crane and Tiger are actually viable and useful in encounters unlike the last time, and we have two new styles; Snake and Boxer, and while Snake is an awesome and fresh new style with plenty of fun mechanics, Boxer falls a little bit short but is still fun in combos. Oh, and there's also the boss fights, the side content and activities, as Seiryo High is a brilliant, unique, and brand new setting for the RGG franchise, the music, the writing, the character interactions, and the majority of the new characters: with my favorites of the bunch being Kuwana, who is the best antagonist in the franchise, Sawa, and Amasawa, who is the best substory character the franchise has seen, (although there are duds like Koda and Bando), hell even Akutsu, Tesso and Soma, as relatively minor as they all are, are still pretty great and memorable despite their lack of screentime comparatively, and there's also the storytelling, which is deliciously gripping, enthralling, and morally complex all the way through, and on par with the great storytelling of the previous game, maybe even slightly better, as the first game had a bit of an issue with its pacing.

Even though the narrative's government conspiracy kind of trips over itself in the last few chapters of the game, the positives far outweigh the negatives, as I think it's a very refreshing, unique, and engrossing story narrative, tackling themes and topics the mainline Yakuza series wouldn't even dare to touch, like bullying and suicide, and what kind of damages it inflicts upon society and its people, and how various people get caught in the crossfire of it all. People might say the story's worse because it's less personal; and I'd say I disagree with that notion because while it may be a bit less personal than the first game, it still fits the Yagami squad's M.O as detectives, taking on various morally complex jobs and stories, and it does the job perfectly.

The only things that fall a bit too flat here are the detective and courtroom aspects, as they feel way too simplistic and tacked-on, and don't really require too much critical thinking to solve, and that Mafuyu does absolutely fucking nothing in this game, and by GOD, I hope JE3 fixes that because these two issues have been plaguing the Judgment series since day one. There are also some other small gripes I have, like some of the bullies' redemption arcs feel a wee bit rushed (looking at you Akane and especially Sakaki who barely counts as a character compared to the other two and on his own), and the sexual harassment plotpoints being a bit weird (they technically make sense but still feel lowkey in poor taste), that and the boxart is uhh... yeah it's bad, not even gonna sugarcoat it. But, despite the negatives, I'd say that the game is still more than the sum of its parts in the best way possible.

If I had to describe this game's narrative in a single word, it would be... morally grey. No one's right in this whole situation, but no one is wrong either, and no single perspective is correct, and that's the beauty of it all, honestly, I rarely see video games approach morally gray topics like that, and I'd say Lost Judgment aces it pretty well! so in short, it's absolutely peak, play the Judgment games now!

See you in Judgment 3! (it's gonna come out sooner or later by the way, Johnny's and Associates is out of commission, and Takuya Kimura has a YT channel, and there's also that big announcement Yokoyama was talking about https://twitter.com/Okami13_/status/1740800530056712454 so it's only a matter of when at this point)

Reviewed on Feb 23, 2024


13 Comments


2 months ago

Need a Judgment 3 with Ace attorney cross examining mechanics or something it'd be the best game ever.

2 months ago

@Oshha SO TRUE

2 months ago

My only problem with the story was "Sawa-Sensei" name being dropped every 5 minutes and a lack of build-up to some moments and character archs.

Outside of that, it's a good gaem

2 months ago

@Moister Man how did I know this was gonna be brought up lmao
I personally think Yagami does that because he thinks it's the most effective way to get to Kuwana's head in order to change his mind about his vigilante bully-killing sprees, since Sawa's pretty important to him, that and it could possibly remind him of the way both Emi and parents died (granted he could've brought up a bit more reasons against him, but it still makes sense)

2 months ago

it doesn't bother me to the same extent, i think Yagami's characterization in Judgment is slightly better, but that's comparing a 9.9 to a 10. I also think Judgment's Kamurocho is the best city, but this is only Yokohama's second game so I can't really fault it for not being as tight.

2 months ago

@MikoMango Yeah, I get where they wanted to go with Sawa but there is a big lack of build up to her. Or name her indirectly emphasizing her death first. Yagami treats Sawa like a childhood friend which isn't wrong knowing Judgment Yagami but still comes off as weird

2 months ago

@Moister yeah, honestly should've had a bit more screentime alongside Yagami before her death :sob:

2 months ago

This comment was deleted

2 months ago

This comment was deleted

2 months ago

@MikioMango i mean i get why he kept name dropping her but I wish he tackled kuwana and kusumoto with alot more variety, best example was the taxi scene but overall PEAK FICTION

2 months ago

Cant play around in this website no more...make one mistake its over...

2 months ago

"but I wish he tackled kuwana and kusumoto with alot more variety," that's what I said lmao @mayaheemayahoo

2 months ago

@Lemonstrade I'm a bit late to this, but thank you so much for giving my review a like! Your reviews are really damn good too, ngl

2 months ago

@MikoMango Always glad to help a Yakuza fan out! Your serious writeups (like this and Kaito Files) feel nice to read, hope there will be many more to come! Also appreciate the kind words :D