Perhaps because I had no expectations, I liked this. However, I can also understand why people were disappointed. Generally, artwork is very beautiful and voice acting is superb. First act of the game is really good, though puzzles are a bit easy. The story is captivating, writing is also great with funny dialogue. In the second act, however, it all wents downhills. Story becomes a cliche "save the people you love" thing instead of a tale about adolescence. Puzzles became ridiculously hard, with little to no hint. This act really brings down the game, but I still would say it's at least worth playing.