I haven't finished this version, but I can say that they definitely did some necessary QoLs everyone appreciated. Here's the thing, as most people agree on that: I don't like the graphics choice, the game has way too light while the original one managed to do a perfect balance with its gorgeous toon-shading.

Is it the definitive version to play by the gameplay? I wanna say yes, but the Tingle Bottle (that substituted the funny GBA function) doesn't work anymore since the Miiverse is forever shut down.

I will consider it an 8/10 because sure, at basis is Wind Waker: it plays like it and looks like it. Just not as good.

My suggestion would be: check both versions and see which one suits you better.