I honestly have no idea how to rate or review these. Do I think FNaF 2 is better than the first? Yes, probably. It expands on the mechanics introduced in the original and builds upon the story and lore. In that way, it's a good sequel. The problem is I don't actually care much about what it's doing and it doesn't do much to fix any of the many issues from the first. It also isn't able to ride off nostalgia in the same way the first does for me. I had a decent time playing it though, I guess.