Common Rockstar W. Most immersive game I've ever played but pooping horses ruin my screenshots! Absolutely peak gaming experience. I'd rather have r* make RDR3 before GTA 6. First few chapters may seem like it's repeating itself a lot, like they find a new place to stay, Dutch has a PLAN that puts em in danger and gets them closer to their foes and the gang ends up moving to a new place, but holy shit the plot, mission design and dialogues definitely kept me engrossed and hyped throughout. I don't get why folks hate Chapter 5, it felt like something that was short, fresh and definitely fun. The whole Guarma segment felt like a Far Cry game but actually fun. And everything post chapter 5 are absolute banger stuff. The shooting mechanics feela bit underwhelming but given with how lengthy the game is, you'd start getting used to it in a good way. Love how you can see an actual rat running around Micah's place during the last mission.
P.S Arthur dying with honor definitely makes more sense and flows better when you consider the story as a whole.