Flawed, but with great stuff too. The story and setting are both interesting and I absolutely love the way that character setup is used to change how you interact with the rest of the world. There is some genuinely great stuff at play here, but the combat, looting, and dialogue were never enough to really make the great material seem worth it.

If you're more used to these top-down rpg style games than I am, maybe the flaws wont be as big of a deal and you can properly enjoy the good stuff. But that just wasn't the case for me so I have a more difficult time giving my full endorsement.