Also played on DS years later, but this one hits home, used to play with my dad, he kept his copy from before I was born, it was fun to revisit his notes in the Journal that the game used to come with. Once my mom bought me Myst 3 on Xbox cuz she remembered the game, but we didn't have an Xbox in our house so it was always a fun "wonder what that game was like" for years after, too. Just lots of fun memories around this one, so it gets that perfect rating, but I can understand that it's a little slow and esoteric for a lot of people who just want a game to be a fun button masher or fun interactive story.