it was fucking great, i love all the characters even when some took their time to show their true colors, but they're all interesting with distinct personalities. The mystery itself is really well executed that i was doubting the main conflict, are there 18 or 19 people on this island? Even with the first half being slow it helped me get accustomed to the setting and characters. The music was great too, it has some basic background tracks but when it wants to shine it fucking nails it. My only issue is that the first day has some really boring padding like George talking about war or few characters talking about gold on the beach that could easily be changed to something much interesting.