It would be cool if there were more than 4 characters and no "literally who" e-celebs in PN3.

Nightmare blunt rotation:
Max Payne
Vaas
Handsome Jack
Joker
Agent 47
Postal dude
Eric Cartman
Plankton

Dream blunt rotation:
Coach (L4D2)
Elizabeth (Bioshock Infinite)
Revolver Ocelot
Garrus
Dandelion (The Witcher)
Joe Barbaro
Finn (Adventure Time)
Scooby

King Dice from Cuphead as the dealer.

@0cean good list! I like the idea of having a big pool of characters to switch off in case the banter gets boring, but I feel like the ecelebs and the literally who characters were also part of the charm of Poker Night given Tycho and Brock.
King Dice as the dealer is a baller choice tho

My fucker stack
Travis Touchdown
Master Shake
Ramona Flowers
Eli Vance

And the dealer has got to be fucken the Stanley parable guy