This is one of those rare games where I think it's amazing and everyone should play it, but I also think it's incredibly overrated.

It's not groundbreaking or changing the genre in anyway, despite what all the reviews and hype seems to suggest. It's just a really, really good metroidvania that understands the genre perfectly. Its full of secrets that are fun to explore, and it really felt like I would rarely go the "wrong way".

That said, the only thing stopping this from being 5 stars is the save points system. It feels really out of place in a game like this, with such a focus on puzzles. Either spawning in the room you died in, like Celeste, or just having way more save points would have made this game so much easier to play - especially towards the end

Reviewed on May 13, 2024


5 Comments


23 days ago

Not even trying to white knight animal well here, but how can a game be overrated if you gave it a 9/10 and said it would have been 10 if it wasn't for the save system?
More that it's overrated in weird ways. It's an amazing game, but I feel like it's being praised for and compared to things (I seen Outer Wilds a lot?) that it doesn't do. And those expectations can harm the game, it did for me at the very start
The game is an absolutely top tier metroidvania, but I don't think it does too much new and unique. And that's fine!! But I feel like so many games get held up as groundbreaking instead of people just letting them be great within their own genre. Something doesn't need to be new and inventive to be good.

23 days ago

For what it's worth, I do think it's one of the first popular games to do the Tunic/La Mulana secrets system. Tunic was popular enough but the reach that this game has is pretty impressive comparatively. A lot of the endgame secrets are very impressive and very cool, and I would argue that not a lot of games are doing it

23 days ago

I don't think I would call it groundbreaking either but overrated feels a little harsh for the ingenuity of its puzzles in the endgame, is what I'm trying to get at I think. I do think I'm sitting at a similar score though