Gameplay- The gameplay in Detective Pikachu Returns largely echoes its 3DS predecessor, maintaining the core mechanics that fans of the franchise have come to appreciate. In this sequel, players once again step into the shoes of Tim Goodman, the determined son of the missing Detective Harry Goodman. The primary objective remains unchanged: explore various locations within the bustling metropolis of Ryme City, gathering clues and tackling puzzles that are integral to each chapter's mystery. However, there are notable departures from the original game. One of the most glaring differences is the fact that the game doesn't have open-world exploration. Instead, Detective Pikachu Returns adopts a more linear approach, restricting players to explore specific areas that are relevant to the current point in the narrative. This limitation can be somewhat frustrating for those who enjoy the freedom of exploring interconnected maps. The puzzles in Detective Pikachu Returns maintain a sense of creativity. For example, in the early stages of the game, players are tasked with finding an Applin among a pile of apples that have spilled out of a crate. These puzzles add a layer of enjoyment to the gameplay, and they help to break up the investigative aspects. A significant enhancement to the sequel is the introduction of assistance from various Pokémon. Detective Pikachu can now call upon these creatures to aid in the investigation. For instance, Growlithe can track scents, Darmanitan can remove large obstacles, Luxray possesses the ability to see through walls, and Pangoro is proficient at moving boulders. This addition not only adds diversity to the gameplay but also reinforces the collaborative nature of solving mysteries in the Pokémon world. It's worth noting that Detective Pikachu Returns is designed with a younger audience in mind. As a result, the gameplay is relatively easy, and it would have been a valuable addition to include a difficulty level selection to cater to players seeking more of a challenge. One of the more significant drawbacks of the game is its lack of replay value. While there are tasks to complete when interacting with characters and Pokémon throughout Ryme City, there is no tangible reward for these efforts. As a result, there is little incentive for players to continue exploring beyond the main story, limiting the game's longevity unless you're interested in replaying the same narrative. Another minor but notable frustration is the inability to skip cutscenes. Some players may prefer to bypass certain dialogue or scenes, and the absence of this feature can be bothersome, particularly on repeat playthroughs. In essence, Detective Pikachu Returns remains true to its 3DS roots, offering a similar experience but adapted for the Nintendo Switch. Nevertheless, it falls short in terms of post-story content, leaving players with limited engagement outside the main narrative. For any potential future Detective Pikachu games, there is ample room for improvement in these areas, ensuring a more well-rounded and captivating gaming experience.
Graphics- When Detective Pikachu Returns was first revealed at an investor's meeting in 2019, I held high hopes for the game's graphics. I expected them to be on par with the visually impressive titles like Pokémon Let's Go Pikachu & Eevee, as well as the highly anticipated Pokémon Sword & Shield. In 2020, when New Pokémon Snap was announced, I was further convinced that the game's graphics would be of the highest quality. New Pokémon Snap, in my opinion, set a new standard for how Pokémon games could look. So, when Detective Pikachu Returns was officially announced in June 2023, my excitement reached a fever pitch. However, the reality fell short of my expectations. The graphics in Detective Pikachu Returns, I must admit, were a letdown. They resembled visuals from older Nintendo platforms such as the 3DS and Wii, and even mobile games. This was a significant disappointment for me, given my high expectations for the game's visual fidelity. What exacerbated this disappointment was the fact that the in-game cutscenes didn't quite match the facial expressions and animations of the characters (Detective Pikachu being the exception) at appropriate moments. This inconsistency in animation quality was particularly noticeable and detracted from the immersion of the game. On the bright side, the game's user interface (UI) design was not terrible. The UI, particularly in Tim Goodman's notebook, remained authentic to what one would expect from a detective's tools. However, I believe that a more engaging and visually appealing design, like the one I've provided here (shows image of an edited design for the case notes menu), could have enhanced the overall experience. This would have added a layer of engagement that was lacking in the actual game. Performance-wise, Detective Pikachu Returns does not run terribly. Despite the mediocre graphics and cutscene issues, the game manages to deliver a smooth and enjoyable performance. This, in combination with the decent UI design, makes it clear that the development team put effort into ensuring that the game runs well, even if it doesn't look as stunning as fans might have hoped.
Story- "Detective Pikachu Returns," the narrative unfolds within the bustling urban landscape of Ryme City, just as in the original Detective Pikachu adventure. Returning players will feel a sense of familiarity with the game's chapter structure, but newcomers need not fret, as the story welcomes both old and new audiences alike. Pikachu graciously provides a concise recap at the outset, ensuring everyone is on the same page. Once again, players are thrust into the charming world of Pikachu, the witty and endearing detective, as he reunites with his friend Tim Goodman. Together, this dynamic duo embarks on a new series of enthralling mysteries, each one shrouded in the enigmatic aura that surrounds Pikachu's seemingly supernatural detective abilities. The stakes skyrocket when Tim's father, Harry Goodman, mysteriously vanishes, casting a shadow of uncertainty over their cheerful partnership. "Detective Pikachu Returns" takes players on a gripping adventure as they navigate the labyrinthine streets of Ryme City, searching for elusive clues and unraveling the intricate web of intrigue that surrounds Harry's disappearance. As the game unfolds, players will have the opportunity to interact with an eclectic array of Pokémon, including some introduced in more recent Pokémon titles. These encounters infuse the game with a delightful sense of variety, allowing fans to forge connections with different Pokémon as they work tirelessly to solve an assortment of engaging puzzles and mysteries. For those who've had the pleasure of watching the Detective Pikachu movie, the story may feel somewhat predictable, but it retains an undeniable charm. However, for newcomers, "Detective Pikachu Returns" offers a captivating journey into the unknown, where every twist and turn takes on an element of delightful surprise. Beyond the storyline, the game is marked by commendable writing that keeps players engaged. While certain plot elements may occasionally follow predictable paths, they do so in an entertaining and enjoyable manner. The humor woven throughout the narrative consistently hits the mark, ensuring players are not only engrossed but also amused by the unfolding events. Furthermore, the game demonstrates exceptional prowess in terms of narrative structure and character development. "Detective Pikachu Returns" expands on the personalities and relationships established in the original title, allowing players to delve deeper into the lives of its endearing characters. A standout feature of this sequel is the inventive use of Pikachu's flashback scenes in the vibrant Bamboo Borough, which adds an extra layer of depth and nostalgia to the experience. These well-crafted flashbacks serve as both a homage to the past and a testament to the game's creativity in storytelling.
[Summary]
Gameplay: 8.3
Graphics & Performance: 6.2
World Building: 6
Story: 8.5
Writing: 8
Characters: 7.5
Sound Design: 7.4
Content: 5.6
Difficulty: Easy
Length: 15-20 Hours
Audience: 7+
Perk: Play Then Sell
Final Score: 7.4/10- Detective Pikachu Returns manages to capture the essence of the Pokémon universe while introducing some innovative elements. The gameplay, with its engaging detective mechanics and clever use of Pokémon in puzzles, keeps you immersed in the colorful world. However, the graphics fall short of modern standards, and the game's world-building misses opportunities for depth and exploration. The story is a strong point, seamlessly extending the original narrative while introducing intriguing new characters. The writing is a highlight, crafting an immersive experience filled with humor and well-timed wit. The characters, including Rachel Myers, are well-developed, although the inclusion of Tim's supposedly deceased mother may confuse fans. The jazz music enhances the atmosphere, but the lack of meaningful content beyond the main story is disappointing. The game's accessibility and simplicity make it suitable for younger players, but it may leave adults wanting more. With a playtime of 15-20 hours, Detective Pikachu Returns offers an enjoyable experience, but its replay value is limited. It's a game worth considering, especially for Pokémon enthusiasts, but waiting for a price drop or purchasing it second-hand might be the best approach.
Graphics- When Detective Pikachu Returns was first revealed at an investor's meeting in 2019, I held high hopes for the game's graphics. I expected them to be on par with the visually impressive titles like Pokémon Let's Go Pikachu & Eevee, as well as the highly anticipated Pokémon Sword & Shield. In 2020, when New Pokémon Snap was announced, I was further convinced that the game's graphics would be of the highest quality. New Pokémon Snap, in my opinion, set a new standard for how Pokémon games could look. So, when Detective Pikachu Returns was officially announced in June 2023, my excitement reached a fever pitch. However, the reality fell short of my expectations. The graphics in Detective Pikachu Returns, I must admit, were a letdown. They resembled visuals from older Nintendo platforms such as the 3DS and Wii, and even mobile games. This was a significant disappointment for me, given my high expectations for the game's visual fidelity. What exacerbated this disappointment was the fact that the in-game cutscenes didn't quite match the facial expressions and animations of the characters (Detective Pikachu being the exception) at appropriate moments. This inconsistency in animation quality was particularly noticeable and detracted from the immersion of the game. On the bright side, the game's user interface (UI) design was not terrible. The UI, particularly in Tim Goodman's notebook, remained authentic to what one would expect from a detective's tools. However, I believe that a more engaging and visually appealing design, like the one I've provided here (shows image of an edited design for the case notes menu), could have enhanced the overall experience. This would have added a layer of engagement that was lacking in the actual game. Performance-wise, Detective Pikachu Returns does not run terribly. Despite the mediocre graphics and cutscene issues, the game manages to deliver a smooth and enjoyable performance. This, in combination with the decent UI design, makes it clear that the development team put effort into ensuring that the game runs well, even if it doesn't look as stunning as fans might have hoped.
Story- "Detective Pikachu Returns," the narrative unfolds within the bustling urban landscape of Ryme City, just as in the original Detective Pikachu adventure. Returning players will feel a sense of familiarity with the game's chapter structure, but newcomers need not fret, as the story welcomes both old and new audiences alike. Pikachu graciously provides a concise recap at the outset, ensuring everyone is on the same page. Once again, players are thrust into the charming world of Pikachu, the witty and endearing detective, as he reunites with his friend Tim Goodman. Together, this dynamic duo embarks on a new series of enthralling mysteries, each one shrouded in the enigmatic aura that surrounds Pikachu's seemingly supernatural detective abilities. The stakes skyrocket when Tim's father, Harry Goodman, mysteriously vanishes, casting a shadow of uncertainty over their cheerful partnership. "Detective Pikachu Returns" takes players on a gripping adventure as they navigate the labyrinthine streets of Ryme City, searching for elusive clues and unraveling the intricate web of intrigue that surrounds Harry's disappearance. As the game unfolds, players will have the opportunity to interact with an eclectic array of Pokémon, including some introduced in more recent Pokémon titles. These encounters infuse the game with a delightful sense of variety, allowing fans to forge connections with different Pokémon as they work tirelessly to solve an assortment of engaging puzzles and mysteries. For those who've had the pleasure of watching the Detective Pikachu movie, the story may feel somewhat predictable, but it retains an undeniable charm. However, for newcomers, "Detective Pikachu Returns" offers a captivating journey into the unknown, where every twist and turn takes on an element of delightful surprise. Beyond the storyline, the game is marked by commendable writing that keeps players engaged. While certain plot elements may occasionally follow predictable paths, they do so in an entertaining and enjoyable manner. The humor woven throughout the narrative consistently hits the mark, ensuring players are not only engrossed but also amused by the unfolding events. Furthermore, the game demonstrates exceptional prowess in terms of narrative structure and character development. "Detective Pikachu Returns" expands on the personalities and relationships established in the original title, allowing players to delve deeper into the lives of its endearing characters. A standout feature of this sequel is the inventive use of Pikachu's flashback scenes in the vibrant Bamboo Borough, which adds an extra layer of depth and nostalgia to the experience. These well-crafted flashbacks serve as both a homage to the past and a testament to the game's creativity in storytelling.
[Summary]
Gameplay: 8.3
Graphics & Performance: 6.2
World Building: 6
Story: 8.5
Writing: 8
Characters: 7.5
Sound Design: 7.4
Content: 5.6
Difficulty: Easy
Length: 15-20 Hours
Audience: 7+
Perk: Play Then Sell
Final Score: 7.4/10- Detective Pikachu Returns manages to capture the essence of the Pokémon universe while introducing some innovative elements. The gameplay, with its engaging detective mechanics and clever use of Pokémon in puzzles, keeps you immersed in the colorful world. However, the graphics fall short of modern standards, and the game's world-building misses opportunities for depth and exploration. The story is a strong point, seamlessly extending the original narrative while introducing intriguing new characters. The writing is a highlight, crafting an immersive experience filled with humor and well-timed wit. The characters, including Rachel Myers, are well-developed, although the inclusion of Tim's supposedly deceased mother may confuse fans. The jazz music enhances the atmosphere, but the lack of meaningful content beyond the main story is disappointing. The game's accessibility and simplicity make it suitable for younger players, but it may leave adults wanting more. With a playtime of 15-20 hours, Detective Pikachu Returns offers an enjoyable experience, but its replay value is limited. It's a game worth considering, especially for Pokémon enthusiasts, but waiting for a price drop or purchasing it second-hand might be the best approach.