It did something it didn't mean to do, and created a classic RPG- the execution of the plot is unparalleled. It is not perfect. Not at all, but even so I'd call the complete package a top tier game.

1/3 the length of its competitors, a little bit wimpy 3rd act, pretty basic battle system, nice helping of bugs- who cares? It has atmosphere and sincerity that were once in a lifetime.

It's the setting, a fantasy near- ancient China, that initially sets it apart, but it expands into a story that touches subjects that no other game has done the same since. Improves upon the original in every way. Holy cow