Story: 8.5/10
There are 4 story routes you can take, I have played 3.5 of them. The routes are distinct from each other (in the second half of the game). What makes the story interesting has a lot to do with the many characters' backgrounds, and how it affects the story.

characters: 10/10
I believe that the characters, from personality to background and connection to other characters made the game shine. Although i had favorite characters in the game, i would not want a single character to be removed, as they were all really great.

gameplay: 10/10
The game is split into a story, combat, and at the monastery (Garreg Mach monastery). The combat system is really simple to use, and the use of battalions played a really good exciting role and sometimes necessary role. I did not think i would like the combat as much as I did, but it was amazing. When instead you are in the monastery you get to train character skills, spend time and get affection points from characters, and can view cutscenes between characters. As equally (or more) important to the g as the battle

Music: 8/10