I am judging this game entirely on its current state. Put the PR debacle at release aside and this game is an absolute masterpiece. It's the most authentic and complete Star Wars experience in gaming ever. It's a huge upgrade over the first. And it's an absolute blast. The multiplayer is so fun and immersive and varied and addicting. And it looks absolutely gorgeous. I know this game got a ton of shit on release but it's damn near perfect now.