This game can't make up its mind if it wants to be a grand story, or an open-world immersive sandbox. The story is great and probably one of Rockstar's best, but everything falls apart when it comes to the gameplay. The gunplay is still shit, the movement feels delayed, and the constant mashing of the sprint button is the most annoying shit.
The camp system had a lot of potential to make this game stand out from other Rockstar titles, but they made that shit useless, the hunger system didn't really matter as the penalty of not eating wasn't that grand, and the morality system had no effect on Arthur's actions.

I really wanted to enjoy this game, but I just can't.