REALLY did not grab me at all. It's fun to watch but a misery to play. R* has an insatiable obsession with "realism" in a manner that fully detracts from the gameplay when they go back to things like this. With RDR1, they managed to keep it in check enough to make a fun game with some quirks, but here it defines the experience, and no matter how good the story may be, how fun the character interactions are, it remains absolutely miserable to actually play, particularly with how horrendous the online mode is.