1. Astro Knights Island (4.5/5 Stars)
2. Mythology Island (4/5 Stars)
3. Great Pumpkin Island (4/5 Stars)
4. Super Power Island (4/5 Stars)
5. Poptropolis Games Island (4/5 Stars)
6. Reality TV Island (4/5 Stars)
7. SOS Island (4/5 Stars)
8. Survival Island (4/5 Stars)
9. Virus Hunter Island (4/5 Stars)
10. 24 Carrot Island (4/5 Stars)
11. Spy Island (4/5 Stars)
12. Time Tangled Island (4/5 Stars)
13. Counterfeit Island (4/5 Stars)
14. Cryptids Island (4/5 Stars)
15. Game Show Island (4/5 Stars)
16. Shrink Ray Island (4/5 Stars)
17. Nabooti Island (4/5 Stars)
18. Early Poptropica Island (4/5 Stars)
19. Jade Scarab Island (4/5 Stars)
20. Shark Tooth Island (4/5 Stars)
21. Goofball Island (3.5/5 Stars)
22. Fairy Tale Island (3.5/5 Stars)
23. Ghost Story Island (3.5/5 Stars)
24. Twisted Thicket Island (3.5/5 Stars)
25. Big Nate Island (3.5/5 Stars)