Reviews from

in the past


Twas a typical pokemon experience. I don't have strong feelings about this one.

Eu não achei tão ruim, sério, pelas opiniões que li na internet achava que esse jogo ia ser muito pior do que ele realmente é, entendo as críticas e até concordo com algumas mas acho que teve alguns exageros por parte da comunidade.

O jogo adicionou muita coisa, roupas diferentes, Pokémon seguindo, novas mecânicas no Underground, não precisamos mais usar HM's, muitos lendários e Pokémon no pós-game... mas realmente faltou o conteúdo Platinum e essa é uma das minhas críticas ao jogo.

O visual Chibi eu achei feio nos trailers mas no jogo até que é bonitinho, e fica melhor ainda no modo portátil do Switch, também não encontrei nenhum bug.

Levei 35 horas pra fazer a maioria das coisas, ainda faltou Pokedéx, Poké Tower, alguns lendários e coisas no Underground.

O jogo é mais fácil que o original mas não achei isso ruim, sempre odiei fazer grinding em Pokémon, e tiraram isso de Sinnoh e ainda corrigiram a velocidade lenta da quarta geração, com isso eu gostei da experiência de jogar esse Remakes.

Como eu disse, o jogo não é ruim, tem suas falhas, como falta de conteúdo de Platinum, mas no geral é uma experiência bem divertida.

Nota: 7,5/10

Review na versão brilliant diamond.

The game can be divided into two parts: the part where you have patience for everything and the part where you just want the dialog boxes to go away and for everything to be over soon.
Outside the elite of the 4 there is not much to praise, the series needs renovation.


it's a Pokémon game. I wish I could still gamble... .-.

My go-to example of what a remake shouldn't do. Porting over the story, gameplay, and music to a new system with as few changes as there were made it feel super dated. The gigantic chibi models don't work in 3D like they do in 2D, and the music loses so much of the charm that the originals had. I don't want any more Pokémon remakes at all if they're like this. The most enjoyment I got out of this game was watching speedrunners break it.

This is the only pokemon game which I have both abandoned before completion and traded in for a refund. Which is wild because I have a copy of pretty much every game from every generation, INCLUDING the spin offs, with the exeption of R/S/E, which I haven't hunted down a copy of yet.

nul nul nul nul vraiment très nul

Não é ruim, é um upgrade decente da 4ª geração, vale mais a pena se você nunca tiver jogado o Pearl e Diamond originais ou gostar muito de Sinnoh, de resto, o mesmo comentário que tenho sobre Diamond e Pearl: Rotas e montanhas bem chatinhas de passar, lendários e personagens bem memoráveis e nada que a 5ª gen não tenha superado

Talvez o pior jogo da franquia Pokémon, ou pelo menos o que eu menos me diverti jogando. Tirando o fato de que o jogo é um remake 1:1 de um jogo que precisava de um upgrade, é impossível falar desse jogo sem criticar a movimentação terrível do personagem num cenário 3d apertado onde as paredes aparentemente "grudam" ao serem tocadas. Não houve nenhuma melhoria de qualidade de vida no quesito batalhas. Um adendo, esse jogo foi desenvolvido pela mesma empresa que fez o pokémon home, e ainda sim teve sérios problemas para lançar a compatibilidade com esse app, ou mesmo a conectividade online do jogo.

Me lo descargué, me lo pasé y a tirarlo por la puta ventana.

I’m not gonna lie, I did the walk through walls glitch and skipped the climax of the entire story. The game is just nothing. Repackaged uglier version of a game you’re probably really nostalgic for.
But the grand underground is fun sometimes and they did give veteran players something in the form of the gym rematches. Thats the only two positives.

no começo tava bem divertido, mas algumas coisas eu só entendi melhor no final do jogo como o undeground, as lutas são muito fáceis, fora a elite dos 4 que me deu uma grande dor de cabeça e me rendeu mais umas boas horas até conseguir zerar o jogo, mas ainda foi legal. Espero que os próximos jogos da série sejam mais divertidos.

im not as negative on the game as many others but i do feel like this disregards platinum and thats the best one. although if youre a newcomer and want to experience gen 4, this could be a worthy purchase! it has quality of life features like exp share that make the tougher fights not as challenging as the original game. veterans hate this and i agree with most of it.

Decent overall, the normal trainers on routes are extremely boring to fight, but the gym leaders feel smarter. The elite four and champion are some of the hardest and most fun battles in the series. Decent Pokédex and the lack of Hms is great. Fun game.

I was writing a big ass paragraph until I realized I didn't really care that much. This remake is as good a remake as FireRed or LeafGreen in which it is 100% true to the source, even to a fault. Unlike FireRed and LeafGreen though, BDSP have 3 generations of remakes and 20 years of lessons that were painfully ignored during their creation. Calumniating in a game that is somehow just as good or just as bad as the original game it is based off.

Side note: I like the chibi art style, I don't get the uproar. Y'all wanted a game that looked like Sword and Shield? The N64 tree game? hahaha, you guys are funny.

I didnt even play the originals and this is still disappointing.

Hopefully the lowest this franchise ever sinks.

wow the sinnoh region sucks i wonder if they could make it worse!

I get why people hated this game, but as a very classic and straightforward Pokémon experience on the Switch, it suited my needs perfectly. I don't hate the chibi presentation, but they could've gone for nicer models and better color grading à la Link's Awakening.

This is honestly a take it or leave it scenario. It's unbelievably lazy. A Butchered underground. Worse than the original in most ways. The world is no better off with these games which is depressing to say.


A game that although I really enjoyed it once I got into it, I don't really see the need for it to exist as it does. It was fun to go through after having a pretty healthy break from the series and trying out Empoleon among others but it should be based on Platinum.

My team:

Pingu the Empoleon Lv. 59
Little Mac the Machoke Lv. 60
Zizou the Zubat Lv. 59
Tiramisu the Pachirisu Lv. 60
Jezebel the Mismagius Lv. 61
Jirachi (unnamed) Lv. 58

Very faithful to the DS release, but that makes it feel clumsy as a Switch game. If you find it on a decent sale, it isn't a bad pick up since the original games were good (I bought mine half-off). I wouldn't buy this at 60 dollars.