Is it the best Pokemon game? Probably not, nevertheless, the amount of nostalgia I have for Pokemon Y is unexplainable. I met my favorite Pokemon through this game, It was the first Pokemon game I completed on my own and I cried when I lost the box for the game. Just too much good memories to ignore.
Positives:
+Added the Fairy type
+Mega Evolutions
+Some cool new pokémon like Sylveon, Tyrantrum, Greninja, Malamar, Pangoro, Dragalge, Zygarde, Diancie, Yveltal, Aurorus, Hawlucha, etc.
+Viola is a top-tier waifu.
Negatives:
-This game is brain-dead easy to the point of not being very enjoyable at all.
-The AI is so dumb it might also be called an "Artificial Stupidity"
-Most characters are bland and forgettable.
-Mega evolution was poorly implemented in the sense of some pokémon who received it were already strong to begin with (Garchomp, Tyranitar) or would've appreciated more a regular evolution instead (Banette, Sableye, Mawile).
Enjoyment: decent for the first 5 minutes then quickly got bored.
+Added the Fairy type
+Mega Evolutions
+Some cool new pokémon like Sylveon, Tyrantrum, Greninja, Malamar, Pangoro, Dragalge, Zygarde, Diancie, Yveltal, Aurorus, Hawlucha, etc.
+Viola is a top-tier waifu.
Negatives:
-This game is brain-dead easy to the point of not being very enjoyable at all.
-The AI is so dumb it might also be called an "Artificial Stupidity"
-Most characters are bland and forgettable.
-Mega evolution was poorly implemented in the sense of some pokémon who received it were already strong to begin with (Garchomp, Tyranitar) or would've appreciated more a regular evolution instead (Banette, Sableye, Mawile).
Enjoyment: decent for the first 5 minutes then quickly got bored.
Terribly underrated Pokémon game. The Pokémon distribution is fantastic, the scenery is quite breathtaking for a 3DS game. As for the difficulty, there is none. But this is a child's game and franchise, if you want it you have to make it yourself. This game is a joy to nuzlocke and I totally recommend it if you've already tried it for the easier games and want something a little more challenging.
I must admit this is a game that has grown on me. The first time I played it I didn't think much of it "just another Pokémon game". But upon trying a few nuzlockes over the years I have come to adore this game. I can't rank it any more than a 3.5, as much as this is one of my favourite games in the series, as just as with many other Pokémon games, it requires too much input from the player to achieve it's full potential (You have to nuzlocke it, maybe even use external tools to randomize etc). However, this is an issue all Pokémon games have.
I must admit this is a game that has grown on me. The first time I played it I didn't think much of it "just another Pokémon game". But upon trying a few nuzlockes over the years I have come to adore this game. I can't rank it any more than a 3.5, as much as this is one of my favourite games in the series, as just as with many other Pokémon games, it requires too much input from the player to achieve it's full potential (You have to nuzlocke it, maybe even use external tools to randomize etc). However, this is an issue all Pokémon games have.
I have so many fond memories of this game in my senior year of high school. The additional local and online communication features made it fun to play with people. As usual for a Pokémon game, the story leaves a bit to be desired but the ending really struck a chord with me. To date, still my most played 3DS game.
7.5 - I put a LOT of hours into this game as a kid mostly with competitive breeding & shiny breeding but as an adult I realize that this game is incredibly bland. Couple of great pokemon additions, Luminose is awesome, and mega evolutions are one of the best things they've done with the franchise but my god everything else is just meh.