Absolutely my favourite OG Sims expansion pack. So much content, so much whimsy, mild spooks. It was also incredible how the spells synergised with other packs that you owned e.g. being able to cast spells on pets.
the best pack...
The Sims: Making Magic is, while not my favorite, on of the better packs in the sims as well. I feel that besides personal opinions The Sims expansion packs just kept getting better and better with each newest one. Making Magic being the last is most likely the best, adding the most interesting and funky items and features out of all 6 before it. This really foundationalized the more fun aspect of the sims, pulling away from a strict life sim, into a quirky life sim with its own personality. Overall a great addition to The Sims, and an even better conclusion to a great first game.