I personally think this is still easily the second best animal crossing. This to me is exactly what ac as a series should be. While i would rate Dōbutsu no Mori e+ probably 4.5 as it is just the definitive version of this game, adding onto whats already an amazing experience (a shame it was never translated over), this easily deserves its rating. The villagers have a certain sass and realism to them that you just cant find in the newer games, they interact with you as if you're actually THERE living in the town. Obviously its gameplay loop is outclassed, kinda clunky and outdated compared to the future entries but it still has that nostalgic and enjoyable vibe to it that just gives off Animal Crossing to me. I LOVE this game, even if it is outdated.