Red Dead Redemption 2 is the best story Rockstar has told, while being one of it's more shakey gameplay experiences.

the gameplay, while it's roots are fun, adds all these side systems that bog the rest of the experience down. cleaning your gun, cleaning your horse, and all these side systems that needlessly effect the main experience, just end up slowing it down.

the story how ever, is perfect. it's a very big, very slow story, about family, loyalty, and fate. all these characters, moving in their own directions, all being their own people, and perfectly forming a wonderful story.

gameplay gets a 3.
story gets a 5.