When I started playing Firewatch I expected a short, cozy exploration game with a heavy focus on Story, which is sort of what I got:

(++) The absolute best thing about this game was hands down the voice acting. Without it the game would've not even had half the charm it has now, it was a delight listening to the conversations of the two protagonists. +1 for the numerous dialog options you can take.
(+) The atmosphere created is absolutely fantastic. The color filter(s) used together with the assets create a great atmosphere and the developers proved that they know how to set a mood.
(+) The sound design and music was really beautiful and really involved me into the entire world.

(+ -) The story: the story was overall really interesting and I loved the vibe between the characters. The mystery aspects was sort of really cool and I did not expect that. However, I was a bit disappointed with the ending, or at least part of it.

( - ) At first, walking around the map was really nice, to explore some new and nice scenery, but the more the game sent me around the map, the more it felt like a chore. Especially towards the end where I had to revisit certain areas over and over again.
( - ) Maybe that is just me but it was, especially at the beginning, super easy for me to miss dialog because i missed the interface pop-up or clicked on something / walked somewhere that brought me to the next dialog already. Controls were a bit of ''getting - used'' to but then was fine!

SPOILERS (smol ones):
( - - ) The game started off as a cozy, quiet game seemingly going towards a sad and emotional story. Somewhere in the middle it changed it's direction towards mystery / crime solving, which I enjoyed a lot at first. However, at some point, the first jumpscare (being hit in the head from behind) scared the absolute shit out of me. There were about 1-2 more jumpscares in the game and most of the vibe of the game from this point on was spooky and scary. I felt extremely nervous and anxious, afraid of another jumpscare. I am quite prone to jumpscares so I really got spooked at about 2 of them. I personally did not like the game including that when supposedly being a cozy exploration / story game. From that point on, I felt like i just wanted to get through the story and I was afraid of exploring further on my own. I felt like something was creeping up behind me all the time and I just felt overall nervous and scared the entire time. That did ruin the experience for me personally, but I absolutely understand people that give this game a high rating! Other's certainly are less easily to be spooked than me, so they will certainly enjoy this game, but for me it was hard to play after that!

Reviewed on Dec 26, 2023


Comments