Fun but the brilliance that makes demons souls is long gone(with some exceptions like the smouldering lake) the didn't realized that the strong part of the souls combat was not the offensive maneuvers but the defensive ones, instead of acting like a adventure using both the scenery and equipment to deal with the odds, you just roll and hit roll and hit roll and hit in 70% of the bosses, I give 4 stars because it's still fun, just not inventive fun