This is an amazing game, it has easily the best story, gameplay mechanics, characters and graphics. Although I think people overrate it a bit, I do love everything on display here.

I really love this game, I like John Marston is more than Arthur and I love all the characters. I think this game works on its own, but got even better after RDR2 was made.

I actually really like this game, I think the gameplay (while not as good as RDR n RDR2) is still good, the characters (especially Red) are cool and setting is perfect.

A good dlc, although gets a little repetitive after a while. I think it’s fun to see these characters like this and have fun with this otherwise serious game in this way.

Missed potential, I think everyone agrees on that. There’s so much that could’ve been done here and yet so little was utilized. The game’s just not that fun in the end.