Red Dead Redemption 2 is not perfect, but yet again, no game is. However, it is the most expansive and detailed game so far, and even today, five years later, when it comes to realism, attention to detail, and even graphics, it has not really been topped. Additionally, there are numerous random encounters with various outcomes based on your choices, side quests with the usual hilarious and deep comedy of Rockstar, and an emotional and engaging story about redemption that makes you think about yourself and the world you live in.
The one or two real shortcomings I recognize in this game is that the combat is really mediocre, acceptable yes, but not particularly enjoyable after a number of hours, and that Sadie is a bad caracther because she goes against the message that the game tries to portray, wich is that revenge is a fool`s  game, she is also a mary sure, who can fight dozens of outlaws with little gunslinging experience. otherwise, i think this is one of the best games ever made.