The horrible controls and tepid story are entirely forgivable as the game is an absolute classic. I say this without hyperbole simply because it is unique, at least to me, insofar as it created an atmosphere of pure terror and unmitigated tension. My muscles ached, I woke during the night and had nightmares. It's been a long time since a game has given me such a visceral response. I'm only a quarter of the way through and I'm scared to play again
And so, on the basis of it being so entirely immersive and fresh I give it full marks.

Note: this is the first Resident Evil I've played.