I have never loved and hated a game more than Dark souls 1. The good definitely out weighs the bad in this case but man Dark souls 1’s peaks are super high and for some people have it to be topped but the valleys in between are dreadful. I feel like for every one really good thing there is either something mediocre or straight dogshit like the bosses for example there are definitely stand out fights Artorias, Manus, Bell gargoyles, ornstein and smough, and Gwyn are all really good but there is so many other bosses that are straight garbage Moonlight butterfly, the 50 different versions of the Stray demon, the Bed of chaos, fucking capra demon and his dumbass dogs. Like that’s my issue with this game it has a amazing starting point a mediocre to bad middle and a fantastic ending with some amazing Dlc and that’s my main issue with DS1 it’s way too inconsistent of a experience with that being said I still love this game I just think it’s heavily flawed but that’s fine.